Web preprint
It's Not the Code-Switching: Six Frontier LLM Judges Fail a Pre-Registered Qualification Bar — and the Bar Was Above Its Own Ground Truth's Ceiling
Six frontier judges were backtested against verdicts that had already decided which model serves a live product. All six failed, and the bar itself turned out to sit above the ground truth's own measured ceiling.
- 6 / 6
- candidate judges failed
- 77.1%
- ground truth's own ceiling
- ≥80%
- bar, fixed before any run